Tuesday, 14 October 2014

OUGD603: Extended Practice - Brief 1: Subliminal Messaging Exhibition, Research

Subliminal Messaging, A Definition:

Below the threshold of conscious perception. Used of stimuli. Inadequate to produce conscious awareness but able to evoke a response. 



anything that sends you a message without your Knowledge of It, usuaLLy picked up on by your subconscious mind, oftEn ViolEnt thoughts, that can be left unhaRmed to slowly work its waY intO your brain. pEople rarely catch them, even when they are right in front of their eyes--more obvious than anything.
"he used subliminal messages to own the world."

James Vicary Experiments, 1957





  • James Vicary claimed to find dramatic increases in the sales of Coca-Cola and popcorn when he flashed the phrases "Drink Coca-Cola" and "Eat popcorn" for 1/2000 of a second during a movie.
  • The statistics showed an increase in popcorn sales by 58%, with an increase in Coca-Cola sales by 18%
  • This is perhaps shocking information that led to an enormous response from the public.
  • Individuals as well as legislators imagined possible effects of subliminal perception on the future - a world where everyone was subliminally manipulated to do what perhaps the government wanted them to do
  • In reality though, research on subliminal effects has shown little overall effects in controlled conditions. There is no evidence based in real-world settings done by top researchers on influencing behaviour
  • In 1962, Vicary stated that the study was a fabrication and the evidence now suggests it was. He Never released a detailed description of his study and there was never any independent evidence to support what he claimed.

QUOTE:
"If the human brain could take in the information it needs to build a response from an image below the perception threshold - a message that perhaps directed someone to buy something -he might be able to re-create the shoppers' vulnerability in a myriad of other places. After giving it some thought, he decided the ideal place to test this would be a cinema. And the words to flash on screen should be 'Drink Coke' and 'Eat Popcorn'."

"In the autumn of 1957, he announced that he had installed a tachistoscope in a Ft Lee, New Jersey, cinema and over the course of six weeks - during which some 45,000 people had been unknowingly subjected to his experiment while watching the movie Picnic - he'd flashed those words on the screen for 1/3000th of a second for every five seconds. He reported that  Coke sales had increased by nearly 58% and that popcorn sales had increased by almost 18%."

Source: The Manipulators, Jeffrey Robinson





I believe propaganda is a form of subliminal messaging as its aim is to influence an attitude or a opinion by presenting only one side of the argument. I believe some examples such as 'Daddy what did you do in the great war? by Saville Lumley use subtle, subliminal messaging to influence these ideas. This design by JM Flagg has used sublimanal messaging by highlighting the word 'you' in a different colour to subliminally target the audience.

The 10 Best Subliminal Ads Ever Made



  • Subliminal advertising -- placing fleeting or hidden images in commercial content in the hopes that viewers will process them unconsciously -- doesn't work.
  • Recent research suggests that consumers do sometimes respond non-consciously to cues they aren't consciously aware are there
  • But extremely brief stimuli that consumers are unaware they're looking at is still unlikely to give them the urge to go shopping.
  • Nonetheless, people remain fascinated by allegedly subliminal messages in ads -- even though if something is truly subliminal you shouldn't be able to identify it, by definition. Most "subliminal" ads are happy accidents, or people seeing what they want to see. But some appear to be deliberate, or at least too good to be true.
1. An oldie but a goodie: Who hasn't spent time searching the Camel logo for the image of a naked man with his "cigarette" hanging out?



2. SFX magazine courted notoriety when it altered the typeface of its logo for its Jennifer Garner issue in such a way that the moniker appeared to spell out something else entirely.



3. One of the oldest and most noted examples, the ad's other message becomes obvious when the image is inverted. Seems too good to be true? Wrong. It's a real Yellow Pages ad.

 


4. For years people have claimed the ice on top of the can forms the silhouette of a nude. I don't buy it.



5. Many people think that the appearance of the word "sex" in the Gilbey's ice cubes is deliberate. But think about this: How does that help Gilbey's sell cocktails?



6. What does this island treasury hope tourists will associate with its balmy climate? The answer can be read in the palm trees behind Queen Elizabeth II's shoulders.



7. If this was deliberate, it's a work of genius. But why bother?




PRODUCT PLACEMENT

In recent times there has been a shift from subliminal messaging to 'product placement' in television programmes and films. This is when branded products appear briefly in a scene, however sometimes product placement is as discreet as subliminal messaging and whole scripts are altered in order to sell a product. 
  • '127 Hours', Capital One


  • 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles', Dominos Pizza 


  • 'You've Got Mail', AOL and Starbucks


  • 'The Thomas Crown Affair', Pepsi One




  • 'Little Nicky', Popeye's Chicken


  • 'E.T', Reese's Pieces




  • 'I, Robot', Converse



As well as films, product placement is also used in television programmes. Product placement was made legal in the UK on 28/02/11, however unlike America where product placement can be obvoius and sometimes influence the script, there a number of specific rules such as; the product placement of tobacco, alchohol, gambling, foods or drinks  high in fat, salt or sugar, medicines and baby milk is banned.


Does Subliminal Messaging Actually work? Article by Vox.com
  • Back during the 2000 presidential election, George W. Bush's campaign aired an attack ad against Al Gore's health-care plan that featured a bizarre quirk. Near the end of the ad, the word "RATS" quickly flashed on the screen, barely noticeable, before the words "BUREAUCRATS DECIDE" appeared.
  • Gore staffers first brought it to the attention of the New York Times, which ran a story in which several experts said it looked like an attempt at subliminal messaging. Bush denied it — and the ad was pulled.
NOTE: Possible example to feature in my exhibition?


  • The fracas was part of a debate that's surrounded advertising for many decades: Do subliminal messages actually work? Are we at the mercy of unconscious cues being pumped into our heads by unscrupulous corporations? Or is this all just a bunch of nonsense?
  • Many psychologists, for their part, are skeptical of how much subliminal messages can do. "The general belief is that [subliminal messages] are pretty powerful and that they can get us to do all sorts of things that we don’t want to do. But that isn’t true," says Ian Zimmerman
  • However, subliminal messages do exist. And they can influence people in all different sorts of subtle ways
  • It's not true that advertisers convinced people to drink Coke by flashing messages in a movie theatre - There was just one problem. This study was a total hoax, Vicary later admitted, made up to boost his marketing company. And other researchers were never able to replicate the results. Yet that story still lives on in many minds as fact.
  • But subliminal messages might be able to influence your drinking habits in other ways - Participants who were subliminally primed with the words "Lipton Ice" were more likely to choose this beverage when given a choice between two drinks. However, this effect only happened if the participants were already thirsty
  • Subliminal messages might affect our opinions of political candidates - Back in 2008, researchers at Adelphi University and Emory University decided to replicate Bush's "RATS" ad in a controlled study. They created campaign ads for an unknown candidate in which the word "RATS" flashed subliminally across the screen. That message increased participants' negative ratings of the candidate. Other subliminal messages, such as "STAR" and "XXXX" seemed to have no effect.
  • None of this means that subliminal messages makes us into brainwashed zombies
  • These studies are performed in very controlled environments in laboratories where there isn't much to distract from the subliminal cues. Real life, on the other hand, is full of distractions, which means that subliminal messages might get overrun by other stimuli.
  • Oftentimes, subliminal messages seem to be giving people a little nudge rather than overwhelming their pre-existing inclinations
  • Also, it's unclear how long the effects of subliminal messages actually last. Most studies look for effects within a few minutes or hours — and haven't explored longer time points

The idea of 'Subliminal Messaging' ties in quite well with the research in which I was undertaking for my COP3 research project, therefore I was able to use some of the material and books I was looking to inform this brief.

Does it work?

Do I believe it works?

How will exhibition tackle the subject? For or against?

LOCATION


No comments:

Post a Comment